Is it possible to pull an internal SATA from an external USB drive?

richlevy • Dec 3, 2012 8:15 pm
I'm seeing a lot of sales on external 2TB drives, but I want an internal drive. The problem is that the externals are discounted to be sometimes cheaper than a 'bare bones' internal.

Are all of the externals out there SATA drives? Can I just pull one from the housing and have a drive I can use as an internal or an external or are some connections soldered?
SteveDallas • Dec 4, 2012 9:43 am
richlevy;841698 wrote:
I'm seeing a lot of sales on external 2TB drives, but I want an internal drive. The problem is that the externals are discounted to be sometimes cheaper than a 'bare bones' internal.

Are all of the externals out there SATA drives? Can I just pull one from the housing and have a drive I can use as an internal or an external or are some connections soldered?


I would expect they're SATA drives in a housing. No guarantees, and there are probably some stupid exceptions, but that just makes the most sense from a manufacturing standpoint.

The problem, of course, is that you void your warranty to find out something else is the case.
gvidas • Dec 4, 2012 11:18 am
I'll second the "probably."

I recently went the other direction -- bought a SSD for my laptop, and an external enclosure for the HD that it replaced.

I can't remember ever taking apart an external drive and not finding a standard internal drive inside, but I haven't done it that much.

It seems like something you should be able to find on the manufacturer's spec sheet.
Undertoad • Dec 4, 2012 10:54 pm
As the great Wesley Snipes said, "Always bet on black."

Western Digital Caviar Black, that is, with its industry-unique 5 year warranty.

Going cheap on hard drives is pretty expensive.
richlevy • Dec 5, 2012 7:12 pm
Undertoad;841905 wrote:
As the great Wesley Snipes said, "Always bet on black."

Western Digital Caviar Black, that is, with its industry-unique 5 year warranty.

Going cheap on hard drives is pretty expensive.
I already have two externals for my data backups. Instead of two externals, I want to move to an internal and an external. I would still have 2 2TB backup drives. I'm hoping the initial backup will be faster to an internal than to my USB 2.0 external/ I don't have USB 3.0 in my computer or on the USB drives.