Should you give money to the homeless?

[xoxoxoBruce]

Originally Posted by Clodfobble

My problem is, I've been assured by people who actually work at homeless shelters that the ones who want help--including a meal--know where to get it at any time. I know it's not universal, but around here the charities and homeless programs are very well funded, and there is no shortage of free food or a roof to sleep under. Most of the homeless that we do have will turn down food if you offer it to them. They'll tell you that what they really wanted was Burger King, not McDonald's, so if you could just give them the money they'll head on over there in a minute or two...

Of course it's a ruse, except for a few pros, they want cash to buy drugs or alcohol. But I feel if he/she doesn't get someone to give them cash, when the shakes get bad enough they're going to try to steal it. I don't think I'm going to change their life with a little cash, (although on occasion I have), but I may help keep them from hurting someone, or getting hurt.

[Spexxvet]

Originally Posted by xoxoxoBruce

Of course it's a ruse, except for a few pros, they want cash to buy drugs or alcohol. But I feel if he/she doesn't get someone to give them cash, when the shakes get bad enough they're going to try to steal it. .

Or do something where they end up in the ER (like drinking sterno) which costs us all more than pocket change.

[Sheldonrs]

My method is pretty simple. If someone asks nicely and I have it to spare, i give it. I don't care if they buy booze with it. I'd probably want to forget my situation for as long as possible too, if it were me.

I also almost always give cigarettes when asked nicely.

[DanaC]

Originally Posted by Sheldonrs

My method is pretty simple. If someone asks nicely and I have it to spare, i give it. I don't care if they buy booze with it. I'd probably want to forget my situation for as long as possible too, if it were me.

I also almost always give cigarettes when asked nicely.

Pretty much this.