So, what is the difference....

[Trilby]

Originally Posted by Undertoad

So the fact he spoke in English to demand ceasefire at Rice is proof that this particular action is directed from Washington?

That's my confusion, too. tw says Washington ordered Israel to fight Hzb. To enact a Final Solution--tw's words. His proof of this is that the Lebanese PM spoke in English to demand a ceasefire to Condi. How does that equal orders FROM Washington TO Israel?

[tw]

Originally Posted by Brianna

That's my confusion, too. tw says Washington ordered Israel to fight Hzb.

No it was not tw's exact words and it misrepresents - big time - the Israel / American relationship. You did not read carefully and you still do not yet understand that relationship.

The US may not have recommended it. But US permission to attack and invade Lebanon – complete with Condi Rice running interference for Israel – is obvious.

If not careful with such details, then Brianna could easily arrive at obviously erroneous conclusions such as:

... it is fucking stupid to ASSUME that the enemy (Israel) would do what it always did in response to kidnapped soldiers.

You see, Brianna, Israel did the reverse- traded kidnapped soldiers for prisoners. You apparently did not know basic details. Even the most militaristic Sharon authorized such trades. You assumed without first grasping details. What I said is also significantly different from what you summarized:

tw says Washington ordered Israel to fight Hzb.

Your mistake implies insufficient grasp of numerous details in this Middle East conflict and relationships. Had you a grasp of the relationships, then you would have better comprehended what was posted, not reposted what I wrote in such gross error - AND why Israel is proxy for a Cheney doctrine.

Somehow you know better and yet don't even understand basic details of a US / Israeli relationship? Credibility? Insufficient grasp of history and facts? Your post implies, at minimum, naivety. Not an insult. Just straight technical analysis. Somehow you know what I have posted is wrong, and yet don't even know basic and obvious facts of this American / Israeli relationship.