Doctor Who - Chibnall's steaming dump

[footfootfoot]

Originally Posted by DanaC

I enjoyed the first couple of eps. Haven't seen the most recent yet.

It feels a lot like classic Who to me.

Doesn't have the complexity (yet - give it time) of davies Who, nor the dark fairytale charm of Moffat's Who - but i find it entertaining. And I love her as the Doctor.

The plots seem a touch thin - but the way she is written is pretty good I think.

I might be spending too much time on r/gallifrey, but I find his writing doesn't grasp the complexity of the doctor. A lot of people there say there is a lot of early doctor in his portrayal of her.

One of the things that bugs me is how preachy and expository he writes her. freshman english comp: Show, don't tell.

The first two were ok, 5-6/10 the Rosa Parks episode was about a 4, and the latest spider one was a 2.

My biggest complaint is that they threw everything out for no reason other than new boss, we're going to do things my way. Got rid of things that worked and tried to redo it in one fell swoop.