June 19, 2010: Table Test

Simple test, which table is bigger?



Do you think the green table looks bigger?

Do you think the red table looks bigger?

A yes answer to either question gets a honk, from Beulah the buzzer.

They are the same size.



More here.

Related, but simpler, and less about being tricked: The Eyeballing Game.

No matter what, it's always eight inches.

Of course it is.

The green one is bigger. It can seat 6 people; the red one can only seat 4.

:lol2: Is Zen aware of this?

gvidas;664388 wrote:

Related, but simpler, and less about being tricked: The Eyeballing Game.

3.81 in 214 seconds

I counted the markings on the rug pattern, and came up with a larger surface area for the red table. I have no ruler, so in my universe, the red one is larger.

5.80 in 100 s

spudcon;664446 wrote:

I counted the markings on the rug pattern, and came up with a larger surface area for the red table. I have no ruler, so in my universe, the red one is larger.

i did the same.

3.68 in 240

2.83 in 242

2.60 in 202

...and now I'm bored and my eyes are spining. Great game for the kids, though

I think they are not the same size. They may take up the same area/amount of space, but one is longer than the other, one is wider than the other. That's two (2) different sizes.:3eye:

Nevermind.

Gravdigr;664748 wrote:

I think they are not the same size. They may take up the same area/amount of space, but one is longer than the other, one is wider than the other. That's two (2) different sizes.:3eye:

Second picture, yellow lines are the same length, as are the blue.

Gravdigr;664748 wrote:

I think they are not the same size. They may take up the same area/amount of space, but one is longer than the other, one is wider than the other. That's two (2) different sizes.:3eye:

Gravdigr;664751 wrote:

[COLOR="Red"]Nevermind.[/COLOR]

The tables may have the same size in pixels on the computer screen, but if you measure them against the square floor tiles, the red table is about 5.25 tiles long and 2.25 tiles wide. The green one is 3.25 tiles wide by 3.25 tiles wide.

If the optical illusion is that "ha ha, some floor tiles are drawn small in this drawing to make you think they are far away" then I don't think that really counts as an optical illusion. That's a standard drawing technique.