The "Plane on a Treadmill" Question

[HungLikeJesus]

Originally Posted by Happy Monkey

Yes...

No.

Or, more accurately, the treadmill is moving at 2X, relative to the plane. It it still, however, only moving at X relative to the ground, matching the plane.

The treadmill matches the plane speed, both speeds relative to the ground. The plane moves at X, the treadmill moves at X in the other direction, and the wheels spin as if the plane were moving at 2X.

But then it's a circular question. For those saying that the plane doesn't move, relative to the ground, X = 0 and 2X = 0, so the treadmill doesn't turn and the plane can't take off. But if the treadmill doesn't turn, the plane can move as normal and will take off as from a normal runway. Which proves that the plane will take off.