[Aliantha]

I didn't mention that because in my opinion it doesn't really have anything to do with him if he's the one that did the dumping. I think that if 9th asks him he's likely to denegrate the girl for his own personal reasons which may then cause 9th even more confusion.

I guess it's up to him. I don't think the other guy has a right to say she can't come in the house though. We've all lived with people who've had friends we don't particularly like but have had to just get over it for the sake of a peaceful existance. I would think this would just be one of those occasions if in fact the other guy has any opinion on the subject at all.