Quote:
Originally Posted by jinx
I completely agree with flint, and yet I see nothing wrong with killing a murderer. So, what do we do?
|
What do we do? Ask ourselves what we hope to
gain through the death of a murderer, and then ask ourselves if this outweights what we
lose through the death of an innocent person who has been wrongly accused and convicted.
Does the death of 1,000 murderers carry more "value" than the death of one innocent person, executed in error? How many murderers do we have to execute to accrue the "price" of one innocent life? Overall, is there
any actual "gain" of
any kind we obtain through the execution of a murderer?
If so, would you knowingly pull the trigger and blow one innocent person's brains out, in order to get whatever reward you expect to receive by executing one million murderers?
These are not hypothetical questions.