The Cellar

The Cellar (http://cellar.org/index.php)
-   Food and Drink (http://cellar.org/forumdisplay.php?f=26)
-   -   Lawsuit pending against Dairy Industry (http://cellar.org/showthread.php?t=9329)

OnyxCougar 10-11-2005 11:59 AM

Lawsuit pending against Dairy Industry
 
This is beyond stupid.
Source

Quote:

Lawsuit Filed Against Dairy Suppliers and Retailers

OCTOBER 10, 2005 -- Ten Washington-area residents filed a class-action lawsuit against milk suppliers and retailers last Thursday in the District of Columbia's Superior Court demanding that the dairy industry place warning labels on milk cartons warning consumers of the effects of lactose intolerance.

According to a recent Progressive Grocer article, the plaintiffs, which include a seven-year-old boy and a Maryland doctor, are targeting dairy producers Horizon Organic, Dean Foods, Nestle Holdings, Farmland Dairies, Shenandoah's Pride, Stonyfield Farm, and Cloverland Farms Dairy and supermarket chains Safeway and Giant Food. The plaintiffs are represented by a lawyer with the Washington-based Physicians Committee for Responsible Medicine (PCRM), a public health group. The group is seeking a required label, such as: "Warning -- If you experience diarrhea or stomach cramps after consuming milk, you may be lactose intolerant. Check with your physician."

"The plaintiffs are suing on behalf of all D.C. residents," said PCRM in a statement released Thursday. "Many area residents are not aware they are lactose intolerant and unwittingly buy milk, only to suffer side effects after drinking it." They also charge the dairy industry with "deceiving the public into thinking that milk is essential."

The group claims that 75 percent of the world's population -- including 60 to 80 percent of African-Americans, 50 to 80 percent of Latinos, and at least 90 percent of Asian-Americans and Native Americans -- is lactose intolerant.

"Because of dairy's unique package of nutrients and important health benefits, the government's 2005 Dietary Guidelines for Americans recommend that people who are sensitive to lactose choose alternatives from within the milk group first, such as lactose-free milk, aged cheeses, or yogurt with active cultures. Research shows that most people who have difficulties digesting lactose can enjoy up to two cups of milk a day, particularly if they drink it with meals," said the International Dairy Foods Association (IFDA) in response to the lawsuit.

"Unfortunately, the legal action announced by PCRM is yet another attempt by this animal-rights group to grab headlines at the expense of sound health and nutrition information," the IFDA continued. "The bottom line is that when it comes to nutrition, people should listen to health and nutrition professionals, not an animal-rights group."

According to The Associated Press, the suit is asking for no more than $100,000 in total damages for the 10 plaintiffs. In June, the Physicians Committee filed a suit claiming the dairy industry and other food companies falsely advertised that dairy consumption helped people lose weight and it is still pending.

wolf 10-11-2005 03:54 PM

The mommy state folks strike again.

Tonchi 10-11-2005 05:47 PM

If they want to sue the milk industry, they can find plenty of reasons other than to save people from not having the sense to stop consuming something which is making them sick. For instance: I discovered that the Feds allow milk producers to put WHITE DYE in the milk fluids because it would not look very appetizing by itself. How many of you knew that half of what you are drinking is artificial coloring? Now you know why sometimes you see swirls on the top of the carton that almost looks like the stuff is separating :sick:

Undertoad 10-11-2005 05:57 PM

Feds allow milk producers to put WHITE DYE in the milk fluids

Please include a link to a non-wingnut website that proves this statement.

Griff 10-11-2005 06:31 PM

Hmmm... it's white coming out of the cow.

Undertoad 10-11-2005 06:43 PM

http://cellar.org/2005/bsmeter.gif

BigV 10-11-2005 06:48 PM

UT, technically, that doesn't come from a cow...smells and tastes the same I reckon, though.

Undertoad 10-11-2005 06:51 PM

(I was just waiting for a chance to use my new meter)

Griff 10-11-2005 06:55 PM

You didn't have to wait too long around here, did you? :)

xoxoxoBruce 10-12-2005 01:31 AM

Could be true.. :confused:
The milk sold today has most of the cream (butterfat) removed. Then there's 2%, 1% and skim.
Back when there was just whole and skim milk, when you poured the skim milk into a glass or on your Wheaties, it was translucent. Whole milk was opaque.
Now, all milk seems to be opaque.

Tonchi 10-12-2005 04:29 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Undertoad
Feds allow milk producers to put WHITE DYE in the milk fluids

Please include a link to a non-wingnut website that proves this statement.

Toad, I'll try to find that in writing for you later. Here's how I found out: While I was living in Phoenix my then-husband was selling copiers. He sold one to a dairy and we drove out there one afternoon to deliver it. While I was waiting for the copier to be installed, I overheard a conversation in that office that some agency was investigating them for not having some measurement required in their milk. I don't remember all the details because that was 20 years ago, but the next morning there was a story about it in the Arizona Republic, and it gave the percentages of "ADDITIVES" which are allowed to be present in pasteurized milk. That's right, additives introduced to the milk outside the cow. The article actually said that white coloring may be added by the producer up to a certain percent of volume (and I don't remember the figures).

As for your "bullshit meter", yep, they find bullshit in the milk occasionally too, as well as in your hamburger, tomatoes, and other delicacies. Isn't that why we need a Federal Government? To inspect and document everything carefully and professionally and never make mistakes so that we are all safe to consume anything in our food supply?????

Griff 10-12-2005 05:54 AM

It isn't added at the producer level, if it is added at all.

OnyxCougar 10-12-2005 07:11 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Tonchi
If they want to sue the milk industry, they can find plenty of reasons .... For instance: ... the Feds allow milk producers to put WHITE DYE in the milk fluids .....


Um...if the feds allow it, then how can you sue the industry for doing it?? I don't get it?

Undertoad 10-12-2005 08:48 AM

Although milk is the most thoroughly tested of all foodstuffs, the Federal Government does not test it.

There is, in fact, no such thing as "white dye". White is the absence of color. Sometimes you can add blue dye to something to make it seem whiter, if it is yellowed; this is why laundry detergent is generally blue, not white.

Sundae 10-12-2005 09:11 AM

I have googled extensively on colouring/ milk/ additives etc, and have not found it yet. In fact cheese makers add more or less dye to their product to counteract the seasonal variations in milk colour.

Non of the anti-milk sites, however much they froth at the mouth, have raised the issue of colour. The only site I found which had any reference at all claimed it was bleached. I haven't included a link as it was a single line unsupported claim.

Still - I have read more about pus and blood than makes me strictly comfortable.....!

jinx 10-12-2005 09:15 AM

MMmmm. Got pus?

BigV 10-12-2005 10:47 AM

Titanium Dioxide

short enough to copy entire article...
Quote:

The Influence of Fat Substitutes Based on Protein and Titanium Dioxide on the Sensory Properties of Lowfat Milks
Lance G. Phillips 1 and David M. Barbano 1

1 Northeast Dairy Foods Research Center, Department of Food Science, Cornell University, Ithaca, NY 14853

The following food-grade ingredients were evaluated as fat substitutes in skim milk: Simplesse® Dry 100 (The Nutrasweet Company, Deerfield, IL), LitessTM (Cultor, New York, NY), whey protein concentrate, sodium caseinate, Dairy LoTM (Cultor), and titanium dioxide. The addition of 3% Simplesse® Dry 100 to skim milk gave milk an appearance that was similar to that of 0.5% fat milk, and mouthfeel was improved to be equivalent to that of milk containing about 1% fat, which is similar to previous results with NDM. Suspension of titanium dioxide in skim milk made the milk whiter, which resulted in improved sensory scores for appearance, creamy aroma, and texture. Skim milk containing titanium dioxide was slightly bluer and greener (i.e., lower b and a values, respectively) than 2% fat milk. Correspondingly, the skim milk containing titanium dioxide was rated lower than the 2% fat milk for visual hang up (a measure of how well milk coats the glass), creamy aroma, texture, and aftertaste. A fat substitute for 2 % fat milk must impart not only the opacity and whiteness of fat but also make the milk less blue and less green. The impact of titanium dioxide on the sensory characteristics of skim milk demonstrated the importance of whiteness. There is clearly a need to develop a whitener for fat-free milk other than titanium dioxide to provide processors with an ingredient option that would improve sensory properties and provide a nutritional benefit.

Key Words: color • milk • fat substitute • titanium dioxide

Submitted on December 26, 1996
Accepted on June 6, 1997


BigV 10-12-2005 11:05 AM

Also interesting:
Why is milk white?
Quote:

Why is milk white? was a question asked in my Summer, 2003 newsletter from the dairy that delivers my milk, Royal Crest Dairy in Denver. The answer given was: "Milk contains casein, a milk protein rich in calcium that is white." Well, whether it is the casein or the calcium that should be white, this answer is incorrect.

The casein is soluble either in the water or the fat of the milk emulsion, and would be colorless and transparent in either case. Calcium, of course, is not white either. Even calcium carbonate is clear and colorless in a good crystal.

The whiteness is due to the scattering of light by the colloidal particles of the milk emulsion. Just the fact that we get white shows that there is no absorption, so whatever is there is transparent. This is true of most whites. The excellent white pigment titanium dioxide is actually made of clear crystals, dispersed as colloidal particles. Nearly all whites are the result of scattering from colloidal-sized particles. Colors, like green, may be produced in transmission by absorption of other colors; no such process can produce white, which in fact is a subjective color, existing completely in the visual sense. White is a very special color.
Minor quibble, UT: White is ALL colors. If sunlight, containing all wavelengths of visible light, is shined on a surface, we'll see what's reflected. When no specific colors/wavelengths of light are absorbed, we see what has been reflected. When we see a color, it is because all wavelengths BUT that wavelength have been absorbed by the object we see of that color. When we see black, we see an object whose surface has absorbed ALL frequencies, leaving nothing, no color, black. When we see white, it's because the surface reflects ALL frequencies of light, so we see all the colors together==white.

tw: these two posts contain technical information about the scattering and absorbtion of light. Proceed with caution.

melidasaur 10-12-2005 11:54 AM

This ranks up there on my list of stupid lawsuits.... why don't we put a label on all food that says - if you eat too much of this you'll get sick and might puke - please consult your physician.

xoxoxoBruce 10-12-2005 12:06 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by melidasaur
This ranks up there on my list of stupid lawsuits.... why don't we put a label on all food that says - if you eat too much of this you'll get sick and might puke - please consult your physician.

:thumb:
Quote:

no such process can produce white, which in fact is a subjective color, existing completely in the visual sense. White is a very special color.
Try to buy white automotive touch-up paint. There are about 4 dozen different whites.

Undertoad 10-12-2005 12:27 PM

They tested it. Good for them! Looks like titanium dioxide is used in milk substitutes such as malk. No evidence it's an additive to things called milk though.

Tonchi 10-12-2005 05:49 PM

I googled it too and turned up a lot about yogurt coloring and not much else useful. In fact, Google seems to become less useful now that everybody knows about it. A few years ago I was able to find the most amazing articles, nowdays it is mostly stuff from technical sites which has nothing to do with what I am wanted. Expanding the capabilities of their search engines has not necessarily made Google better, Yahoo seems to find more of the things I am looking up lately.

I wish the Arizona Republic could let me search their archives from November 1984, because I believe that was when I read about this happening. Well, maybe sometime soon I'll drive out to one of those huge producers we have around here and try to find somebody who will talk about what they did with the milk 20 years ago. Could be that they put a stop to it, but I did NOT dream up reading about it when I lived in Phoenix.

As far as why investigate if it is permitted to add color, they were adding TOO MUCH as I recall. I also remember reading a book called "Beautiful Joe" when I was a kid which described unscrupulous milkmen during Victorian times in the USA adding white powders to the milk because the cows were sickly and their milk was thin. In places where milk comes from small producers and not the huge dairy conglomerates which are taking over entire counties in California, it might be harder to regulate and milk might be sold which did not precisely meet FDA requirements. We milk drinkers in 1950's North Carolina used to dread the early springtime because the cows would be eating sprouted wild onions in the fields and the milk produced had a decidedly onion flavor. With milk being mass-procssed by fewer companies, we don't have that problem anymore and all the milk is uniformly tasteless.

wolf 10-12-2005 09:03 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by BigV
Minor quibble, UT: White is ALL colors.

White is all colors of light, no colors of pigment.

Black is the absence of color of light, and the presence of color of pigment.

And in case you wondered, I typically jaywalk.

BigV 10-13-2005 04:00 PM

Ju tawkin 2 ME?

Rock Steady 10-18-2005 11:34 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by Tonchi
I googled it too and turned up a lot about yogurt coloring and not much else useful. In fact, Google seems to become less useful now that everybody knows about it. A few years ago I was able to find the most amazing articles, nowdays it is mostly stuff from technical sites which has nothing to do with what I am wanted. Expanding the capabilities of their search engines has not necessarily made Google better, Yahoo seems to find more of the things I am looking up lately.

Hey girlfriend, you are right about the G. They boast a large document collection half based on indexing web pages by the text of the anchor rather than actually spidering the page. And Google is now Big Brother filtering as much of your text and email as they can get their paws on. They want to set up free WiFi throughout SF, no thanks.

After Yahoo bought Inktomi and Overture (which had bought Alta Vista and FAST), a group of very smart engineers used the Inktomi search engine as the base code and added features from the other two. The relevance scoring polynomial in that is now really large and complex, but it works well after extensive testing and tweaking.

Try Clusty, it groups topics for you.

http://clusty.com/search?query=white...nt%20in%20milk

You get useful information on the first try.

⇨Paint (62)
⇨Titanium Dioxide (21)
⇨Skin (18)
⇨Definition (15)
⇨Pigment Powders (6)
⇨Cattle (6)
⇨Glossary (5)
⇨Goat's Milk Soap Base (4)
⇨Fresco, Colors on White Pigment (2)
⇨Carton Of Milk (3)

Share and Enjoy

Tonchi 10-24-2005 02:32 AM

WOW! Thanks so much, this should be fascinating to play with the next time I have to find a reference. The only problem is I have a tendency to actually READ all the interesting looking stuff that turns up, which is why I never get any sleep :3_eyes:


All times are GMT -5. The time now is 03:06 PM.

Powered by: vBulletin Version 3.8.1
Copyright ©2000 - 2025, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.