![]() |
Quote:
|
Quote:
Quote:
Quote:
|
Before the white man came, the area that is now D.C. was crawling with Native Americans.
History don't begin with the white man. |
True, but DC isn't unique there. Every city can say the same thing. What makes DC unique is that it's the nation's capital. The team name should reflect what makes this city unique.
|
So let's rename the team to the Washington Power Mad Ego Maniacs.
Or The Dividers. Or The Crack Mayors. Oooooh...The Lobby. :D |
I'm waiting for the cracker industry to stop using the word 'cracker'. It's racist, and highly offensive.
I'm also waiting for reparations from when the gubmint took my land and killed my ancestors with small pox-infected blankets. Whir mah check? |
Dana, shut up with your political correctness already.
Honestly. You're gone mad on it. You'll be banning Jebus next. |
UT, you're on alert five, stand ready to unban JBKlyde!
|
Quote:
If there were an actual disagreement amongst Native Americans as to who should speak for them; and some were saying "nah, keep the name, we like it" and others were saying "find a new name, that's offensive"; I would accept the argument that we should wait and see. But there is no such debate. The way I see it, Native Americans are fairly cohesively saying, repeatedly and forcefully, that they consider "redskin" a derogatory term, and that naming a football team that does not honor their heritage. Insisting that it does is tantamount to saying: "I know better than you how to commemorate your history." |
It's not just their history, it's our history and there have been other cultural groups in better position to give an accounting of it from the time it became a shared history (especially pre-conflict) for the purpose of commemoration. They're not just asserting who makes that decision for their own culture, they're aggressing to make that determination for all cultures. Disagreeing with that is tantamount to saying I know better than you how to commemorate my part of our shared history together. I wouldn't aggress against Native Americans for having a football team called the Palefaces or even the Forked Tongues if that's what commemorates their part of our shared history. If they can't reciprocate, that's their problem:
"No matter how badly you are broken, you can always build yourself back up. It takes time. Don't let your struggle become your identity." |
It's either imperialistic or a complete failure of language to call someone by a derogatory slur and then say, in response to their offense and in all seriousness, "I'm honoring our shared cultural history."
I'd accept the point if the owners of the team were being ironic, or even a little introspective -- if the whole thing was being done to call attention to the rapacious conquest of North America by European colonists. But it's not. It is a continuation of that same conquest, concurrent with denying it ever happened. Native Americans are entirely justified in saying 'I know better than you how to commemorate my part of our shared history together.' That's the point. |
Quote:
Quote:
Quote:
|
Ok. I am out of this discussion. It's gone through the fucking looking glass into bizarro land.
|
I was only here for political correctness Nazi entertainment; so, if Dani's out, I'm out too.
|
Good because we skipped right over a discussion of the fudge industry in Green Bay.
|
All times are GMT -5. The time now is 08:33 PM. |
Powered by: vBulletin Version 3.8.1
Copyright ©2000 - 2025, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.