I think her point is obviously God wasn't in on the plan, and SG shouldn't have to pay for the plan with her taxes just because this chick claimed it was God's will.

I realize she was ridiculing these idiots explaining their bad decisions as God's will... but;
I assume the Brits in question pay taxes like everyone else in the NHS, and obviously must be entitled to make bad decisions under that system.
God did not make these decisions, Brits did. God didn't created the NHS that poured resources into this case as a result of the bad decisions, Brits did.
If you give God no credit, then don't assign God blame.

I don't think she was blaming God either.

The way I read it, she simply quoted what she'd read and doesn't believe God had anything to do with it but that the woman's faith had plenty to do with it and in the end, the outcome was pretty much as the doctors had predicted.

Yup, Ali gets it.
In every account of the story I read, God was mentioned by the parents. Everything was down to God. It just got up my nose a bit that he was still being referenced when both girls were dead and a lot of time and money had been spent on them, against all medical advice.

I don't say any of it is God's fault because I don't believe in him. But his name is often invoked to explain poor judgement.

People that can't, or won't, make reasonable decisions always pass the buck. It's God's will, nature takes it's course, fate intervened, luck ran out, ad nauseum... but it all boils down to bad decisions and a system that caters to those bad decisions, no matter what their excuse.

Taxing God is impossible, and I don't think you have any say in who is involved in these decisions, since you are neither the Doctor nor patient.
If you don't think the NHS acted properly, complain to your elected representative. Tell them to change the system so these people can't waste your money.

Yeah man... I agree!

Yes. Link would have been nice.

Yeah, I agree.

Yeah, me too! I agree!

You know... I agree with you.

I think you're right... I agree with that.

Yeah, I can agree with that.

Uh-uh... what you said makes sense. I'm inclined to agree.

I agree.

Me neither. I agree.





what was this thread about again.... :3_eyes:

You're too darn agreeable. :)

Yes... I agree.

Practicing my New Years resolution.

Wow. Well worth repeating!

If it wasn't God's will, then it was Satan's fault. If neither of those apply, then we need to take personal responsibility for it. But only as a last resort....:rolleyes:

You're right. I was too pissy about it and I do take responsibility for it. Sorry to anyone I ticked off.

Stormie made my point. That's awesome.

I have to live with every bad thing I have ever done. I can't give it to something that does not exist. I have to fess to it, to myself. Then make the changes that need to be made. My sins are my sins and I did not approve a god to kill theirselves for my sins. Don't kill yourself or be killed for any sin of mine. You do not have my approval. They are mine. Kthnx. I haven't done anything that bad anyway. No one needs more gruesome death to be forgiven. That is faulty thinking. I am capable of saving myself. I am capable of living with my own sins. I am capable of forgiving myself. No one needs to do that for me. It's for me to do. If I have hurt someone it is up to me to make amends, and god isn't going to do it for me.

If you disagree, may god forgive me. ;)

I know people feel more comfortable thinking that they have been forgiven by a great power. But I don't live that way. I'm not always comfortable because I have to work on my issues. I can forgive myself when I have done something about them, and an outside entity managing it will not help. That will just give me more wiggle room to keep screwing up now won't it? When I manage it myself I have good character. When I do for myself and then others why would an outside force be compelled to get involved?

Can any of you say that you don't need to be forgiven by god? I can. I can't even figure out what being forgiven by god even involves. I owe no entities an explanation. And if I do, then god itself needs to let me know, because I am currently unaware of being involved with anything that wants to micro-manage my responsibilites, my screw-ups, or my good qualities.

Yup.

I would be grateful if I were forgiven by the people I hurt.

But I also accept that sometimes the hurt is out of proportion to the action. I see that from both sides.

I have had someone claiming near-fatal hurt for something that didn't warrant it. I have also suffered for years over a hurt that was not intended and was possibly prolonged by my own sense of drama (although I believed in the honesty of physically felt emotions at the time).

You know I don't believe in God. But I also don't believe in fate, true love, luck etc. If you said my life was therefore barren I'sd agree. Apart from the therefore part. If I was beautiful, it would differ. And that makes a big difference in your belief systems. Trust me.

I respectfully disagree. Beauty does not make for a full, wonderful life. I know many utterly miserable, gorgeous people.