i totally know what it is.....but i dont want to be 'it'

ppbbbltt

Chilled Beverages

Okay, that was clearly due to sheer lack of sleep/incompetence. Not sure which. Changing it to... popcorn butter?

Does any one else picture LJ bouncing up n down in his seat like an excited schoolboy??

That could be just me though.

Peanut Butter?

nope, nope, nope... and LJ has no idea what it is.

potato bread?

nah

Parsnip blintzes?

No. Really, really no.

polish bratwursts.

Nie

OK, this is a real guess:

poppyseed bagels

That's the one - you're up blue.

Yikes, I haven't been in daddy's grocery store in months...let's see...

Dad owns a grocery store and in it he sells something that starts with A C