The Cellar

The Cellar (http://cellar.org/index.php)
-   Current Events (http://cellar.org/forumdisplay.php?f=4)
-   -   Quake/Tsunami (http://cellar.org/showthread.php?t=24704)

tw 05-24-2011 09:05 AM

From Bloomberg News on 24 May 2011 is what Ken Nakajima of Kyoto University defined. "Now, they have confirmed what everyone expected."
Quote:

Tepco Says Fuel Rods Melted Down in Two More Reactors at Fukushima Plant
Tokyo Electric Power Co. said fuel rods melted in two more reactors at its Fukushima nuclear plant, indicating for the first time that damage from the March 11 earthquake and tsunami is matching worse-case-scenarios.

Fuel rods in reactors 2 and 3 had almost complete meltdowns, spokesman Junichi Matsumoto told reporters in Tokyo today. That’s in line with U.S. assessments in the early days of the crisis that suggested damage to the station was more severe than Tokyo Electric officials estimated.
TEPCO claims to end this crisis in six to nine months. Amazing that anyone would believe anything from TEPCO VP Muta. Three Mile Island with a working cooling system and only a partial meltdown took a year to cool. And another nine years to clean out. Three TEPCO reactors without working cooling systems will be cooled and then cleaned out in nine months? At what point does the obvious finally become obvious? They are still lying even to themselves.

classicman 05-24-2011 10:44 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by tw (Post 736245)
Amazing that anyone would believe anything from TEPCO VP Muta.

Uh, who is?

classicman 06-06-2011 09:56 AM

Fukushima Reactor No. 1 more radioactive than ever
 
Quote:

At the stricken Fukushima nuclear power plant, a robot sent into the building housing Reactor No. 1 on Saturday detected the highest levels of radiation measured since the crisis began on March 11.

According to the Japan Times, The Tokyo Electric Power Company (TEPCO) reported that radiation levels in the air around Reactor 1 were at 4000 millisieverts per hour, an exposure level equivalent to approximately 40,000 chest x-rays. TEPCO says it has no plans to send workers into the area because of its dangerously high radioactivity.

On Friday, a spokesman for TEPCO announced that steam was rising from underneath the reactor building. That afternoon, Japanese national television carried blurry footage of smoke rising from an opening in the floor.
Link

didn't see any of this on tv this am.
Dana, Zen ... I'm interested if it was on BBC or .... ( related other thread )

HungLikeJesus 06-06-2011 11:19 AM

They're sending robots in because it's too dangerous for people?

PETR isn't going to like that.

tw 06-07-2011 04:20 AM

Quote:

Originally Posted by HungLikeJesus (Post 738579)
They're sending robots in because it's too dangerous for people?

In Reactor 1, the containment building was too dangerous for people within the first day. But TEPCO was denying for weeks that a meltdown had occurred.

For some strange reason, operators turned off the emergency cooling system. Then could not turn it back on. People had to go into that building to open valves on the second floor and in the basement. Second floor valves opened immediately. Many people kept going into the basement because those valves would not open manually. And each person who tried was exceeding his radiation levels.

Only hours after the last person left, Reactor 1 exploded. And still TEPCO denied there was any meltdown.

Japan is world leaders in robots. But had to go to America to find one that could withstand the radiation ... that did not exist because a meltdown and containment breech never happened.

Just wondering if Richard Nixon fathered any kids in Japan.

tw 11-06-2011 01:14 PM

We know without doubt that all three nuclear reactors suffered meltdowns. TEPCO refused to acknowledge that for six months. The first meltdown was probably Fukushima Diachi One - sometime before 11 PM or less than 8 hours after an 11 March Tsunami.

Curious is to remember how you thought you saw things back then. Then read how many remains in denial during this discussion. Appreciate why some knew what, when, while so much spin from subjective sources were outright lies. On 12 March,
Quote:

Originally Posted by tw (Post 716309)
Due to insufficient information, one of the five reactors is starting to sound more and more like Three Mile Island. Apparently at least one meter of the boron rods are above water. And some melting has already occured inside that reactor core.

And yet a week later, denials continued.

On 12 March was
Quote:

Originally Posted by tw (Post 716463)
Meanwhile, you should have seen something far more serious. One nuclear plant was in a Three Mile Island event over 24 hours ago. And like Three Mile Island, the 'powers that be' are only saying what they know. During Three Mile Island, that was MBAs lying because they had no idea how a power plant works. Lied so much that reporters openly ignore Met Ed management and openly said so in their reports. We now know Three Mile Island technical people were openly crying for help from the very beginning. And Met Ed MBAs ignore those requests due to complete technical ignorance. Question remains what Tokyo Electric management is. From what they have said, it was obvious before my previous post that the core had melted.

Let's be clear. Three Mile Island was dependent for one year on pumps that were damaged and could have failed at any time. Then the event would have restarted. Yes, Three Mile Island was a crisis for a year. Fukushima One had no way to pump coolant into it. Whether any cooling system can be restored is unknown. We know the building containing the reactor core exploded. And nobody is saying why. That is troubling.

There will be dangerous radiation leaks. Only question is how much.

Two other plants are also suffering less coolant failures.

Just like Three Mile Island, the technical people were crying for help. And getting almost none. Top management was remaining in denial. We now know the tech people in Fukushima resorted to removing and using batteries from their cars only hours after the Tsunami in a desperate attempt to save the reactors. Knew something far worse had happened early on. Technicians in radiation suits that night tried to enter the containment building of Fukushima One. When they opened the door, a large and aggressive white cloud spewed out. They slammed that door immediately. Were not able to take any radiation measurements. Did not dare enter that building. Did not yet know for certain that the entire core was completely exposed and melted. It was not just a partial or near meltdown as they feared. It was a complete meltdown. So TEPCO management denied everything.

TEPCO management said the reactor was still completely covered in water. That white cloud suggested something different.

By 16 March, Fukushima 4 exploded. Top management so removed from reality (as happened at 3 Mile Island) tried to blame that explosion on a hydrogen leakage from Fukushima 3. Meanwhile, 3 workers had already died at these plants. Denials continued even in The Cellar. "The tw speculation is off the charts here; reaction containment has been breeched, and plumes of misinformation, nonsense and confusion can be seen for miles." And "Nope, the NY Times story is wrong. There have been no deaths at the plant." Everyone should learn why so many stayed so far in denial.

By the next morning (12 March), Fukushima engineers vented radioactive gasses from Fukushima 1 in a desperate attempt to avert a containment explosion. We know that these gasses created dangerous radiation levels far beyond the 10 kilometer evacuation area. We know these evacuations were ordered because Fukushima was venting radioactive gases created by a meltdown. Spewing radiation especially far into towns to the NW. We know TEPCO management knew this. And said nothing.

In less than 24 hours, many teams were addressing so many issues as to sound similar to chaos during the Battle of the Bulge. Without any support from TEPCO in Tokyo, employees were performing actions at great personal risk to avert a much larger disaster. That many employees had long since consumed excessive radiation from a meltdown that did not happen.

Radiation levels in Fukushima 1 were so high only 15 hours after the Tsunami that multiple teams could not reach valves to vent radioactive gas into the countryside. Even a week later, many here were still denying all this had happened.

By the end of the first week, we knew (contrary to TEPCO top management claims) that all technical people had already destroyed three nuclear reactors in a desperate effort to avoid an even larger nuclear accident. Salt water was being used only 23 hours after the Tsunami. Because the people who think like engineers knew how bad things were that quickly. Obvious less than a week later only to the fewer who learned how to quickly identify reality.
Quote:

Originally Posted by tw (Post 717014)
Once TEPCO was pouring seawater inside each reactor, then that reactor was being trashed. They were using their last and most destructive option; ... Because events were worse than a rosy picture they were painting. The first of major problems were known on Saturday - less than 24 hours after the earthquake.

Meanwhile, US government officials believe at least one pool containing spent nuclear material is completely dry. That means melting and outgassing radioactivity. The only reason that explains multiple explosions and fires. No reason for this other than mistakes (ignorance) at the highest levels of management. Danger from fuel stored outside the containment vessel is also contrary to what TEPCO wanted everyone to believe. ...

Bottom line reality. Three nuclear reactors are trashed. A fourth is now so radioactive as to be dangerous to human life. Unknown is how operators in two adjacent reactors are dealing with periodic high (but not deadly) levels of radioactivity that must be inside their control rooms. Bottom line - TEPCO has been outputting so much contrary and misleading information that even Japan's Prime Minister had enough - privately scolded TEPCO management for intentional misinformation or complete technical ignorance.

We now know the Prime Minister did not just scold TEPCO. TEPCO was going to evacuate all plants. TEPCO management was so incompetent as to literally sacrifice the Fukushima Diachi countryside to major meltdowns and breeches. The Japanese Prime Minister literally stormed into TEPCO HQs and personally yelled point blank into the faces of TEPCO top management. Only then did TEPCO decide to continue trying to save the plants. Then another nuclear plant exploded. BTW, at what point does a well proven fact become obvious? 85% of all problems are directly traceable to top management. Especially those who use the subjective reasoning techniques taught in business schools.

Last week in September contained two significant events. The United States, in a continuing move to subvert science, shut down its last major research tool into quantum physics. An example of how a technically naive top management avidly wants to destroy future jobs. And TEPCO announced that all three melted plants have finally cooled to less than 100 degrees C. As if the temperature of steam is significant. They ignore that this cooling process must continue for another ten years.

Those numbers do not mean these reactors are safe. In fact, the next week, radioactive Xenon was detected. Xenon suggests that nuclear fission is still ongoing inside one reactor. But TEPCO needed the 'safe' announcement to meet their declaration six months ago of solving the problem by September. As if a TEPCO number (212 degrees F) and spin means a deadline was met.

Up top, were hard facts from 3 Mile Island. The event could have restarted even a year later had a cooling pump failed. None of the 3 Fukushima reactors are safe. An emergency cooling process must continue for another ten years. TEPCO just forgot to mention that part. But then honesty never exists in an organization where profits (or the political agenda) are more important than the product or the nation. This was obvious only seven days after the tsunami and while so many were still denying reality.
Quote:

Originally Posted by tw (Post 717241)
Multiple nuclear meltdown was an event created by men not doing their job to avert what was unnecessary.

Appreciate that many can read the same facts and not see the reality.
Quote:

Originally Posted by monster (Post 717692)
[aside] tw is his own parody, really. not really cricket. [/aside]

[continues in a next post]

tw 11-06-2011 01:22 PM

[continues from the previous post]

An interesting lesson on how reality is obvious only with the right attitude and fundamental training. The situation in Fukushima was so bad so quickly that technicians removed batteries from their cars hours after the Tsunami in a desperate attempt to save the plants. Weeks later, and due to intentional misinformation, many even in the Cellar were still denying that reality. Things were so desperate, even two weeks after the Tsunami, that employees were still taking life threatening risks to save Japan from the plants. The situation was that desperate even weeks later.
Quote:

Originally Posted by infinite monkey (Post 718358)
I don't mean to be rude, but, um...aren't they supposed to be smarter than the average bear? Sorry if that's waisis.

They were not dumb. Despite so many comments here, Fukushima workers were trying to avert something far worse than what I had posted. Due to intentional misinformation (in the tradition of Saddam's WMDs, and BP's Macondo well), so many were still denying reality weeks after facts were presented bluntly (and without doubt) in the Cellar. Even Urbane Guerrilla was taking cheap shots a month later.

Curious are so many who remained in outright denial of a nuclear meltdown when facts with numbers made reality so obvious. Demonstrates that propaganda works so well. This thread makes interesting reading now that we know a minority (who demands hard facts with numbers) saw reality so quickly. A meltdown was obvious within days of the tsunami. But only to the few who have learned how to remove reality from so much propaganda. Who learned why subjective facts are so akin to lying.
Quote:

What is not reported is why the Japanese government only recently obtained these numbers. Tokyo Electric (TEPCO) was doing what any business school graduate would do. Lie. Pretend everything is under control.
And so many actually believed those intentional lies. Even denied that TEPCO considered surrendering and evacuating Fukushima.

85% of all problems are traceable to top management - especially when they forget why hard facts and the numbers are so important. One should learn from this recent history. Ask yourself what you thought back then. Then go read the thread to see how accurately you really saw things.

Half a year later, and TEPCO is still slowly leaking facts about the severity of multiple meltdowns. We can only know this. What actually happened is far worse than what we know. Or what was posted in The Cellar. There were quite a few heroes. The ones who were heroes - we don't know any of their names. Nor the names of so many who were killed or are suffering radiation poisoning - from multiple meltdowns that were not happening.

classicman 11-06-2011 02:02 PM

The more things change, the more they stay the same.
tw is his own parody.

SamIam 11-06-2011 03:45 PM

Oh, tw's OK. You just have to get used to his eccentric style of posting. Often he posts about important stuff. You just need to run the post through your handy tw translator app. Now on sale for 19.95. ;)

monster 11-06-2011 03:53 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by SamIam (Post 770743)
Oh, tw's OK. You just have to get used to his eccentric style of posting. Often he posts about important stuff. You just need to run the post through your handy tw translator app. Now on sale for 19.95. ;)

85% of them are faulty, though

tw 11-06-2011 07:52 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by monster (Post 770751)
85% of them are faulty, though

So you are saying that Eastman Kodak is not going to bankruptcy? That GM has been making good, innovative cars for 30 years? That a Man to Mars and the $billions for Constellation/Orion/Ares makes sense? That an Idle Air Control Valve in a Honda Civic was OK? That George Jr was as honest as Nixon when he sent almost 5000 American soldiers to death? That Comcast did not attempt, on multiple occassions, to subvert the Internet (even skewing Skype packets to harm that service)? That wacko extremists did not all but try to get in a hot war with China? That the electric grid is failing and that CA has a serious energy shortage? That the USS Baatan did not sit for five days off of New Orleans denied permission to help rescue, support, feed, and house tens of thousands of desperate Americans? That Saddam had WMDs and was planning to attack the US?

Clearly those three Fukushima nuclear reactors did not melt down? Management clearly did not deny problems and make it worse?

Apparently it was all only fiction to co-write another Clancy novel. And Monster is only wrong about it 15% of the time. Unfortunately Monster's numbers are not very good. Since Urbane Guerrilla is wrong only 0% of the time.

monster 11-06-2011 08:23 PM

see. fucking app failed again, Sam. or did it work for you there?

tw 11-06-2011 09:19 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by monster (Post 770800)
see. fucking app failed again, Sam. or did it work for you there?

Warning. Malware was embedded in that last post.

SamIam 11-06-2011 10:22 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by monster (Post 770800)
see. fucking app failed again, Sam. or did it work for you there?

Those damn apps are made in China and the quality can be variable. Mine kinda of works although I get baffled at times.

My top 4 fav tw posts:

1) the time I posted about my truck acting up and tw explained the problem almost exactly.
2) His early wmd posts. He was right about those
3) All the posts mentioning incompetent CEO's. tw hated CEO's way before it became fashionable.
4) He's right about W.

tw is like the cellar's pet nerd. ;)

ZenGum 11-06-2011 11:58 PM

Quote:

Originally Posted by monster (Post 770800)
see. fucking app failed again, Sam. or did it work for you there?

The app defaults to TW --> human. He put human talk in and got double human. It just needs a special reverse human --> TW setting.


All times are GMT -5. The time now is 03:48 PM.

Powered by: vBulletin Version 3.8.1
Copyright ©2000 - 2025, Jelsoft Enterprises Ltd.